Marking Explainers Some effort60 min
Use AI for marking and still make every mark yourself
A 60 minute routine for marking a class set with AI: you set the objectives, check the output and decide every mark.
Can AI mark my pupils’ work?
It can draft comments and suggest marks, but you decide every mark. Treat the AI as a fast first reader. It compares work with the objectives you give it. It does not know your pupils, your task or what a good attempt looks like for this class. Your judgement fills that gap.
The aim is to spend your time on the decisions that need you, not on writing the same comment 30 times. Nothing in this routine reaches a pupil until you have read it and agreed with it. Check your school’s AI and data policy before you start. This is not legal advice.
What you need before you start
You need an approved tool, one class set, 3 to 5 objectives and about 60 minutes. Gather the rest before you open the tool, so you do not stall halfway.
- A tool your school has approved for use with pupils’ work.
- One class set, for example 30 pieces of writing of one page or less.
- 3 to 5 objectives or success criteria, written in plain words.
- Your mark scheme or level descriptors, to hand.
- A way to remove names. Use pupil numbers instead, unless your school has approved the tool for names.
- A pen and a pad for your own notes on the first three scripts.
The routine in six steps
Follow these six steps in order. They add up to about 60 minutes for 30 pieces.
- Check your school’s AI and data policy (2 minutes). Never put pupils’ names or personal data into a tool your school has not approved.
- Write 3 to 5 objectives (10 minutes). One line each, in words a pupil would recognise.
- Mark 3 scripts yourself (15 minutes): one strong, one middling, one weak. Note a mark and one comment for each.
- Remove names, then give the tool your objectives and the class set (5 minutes). Ask for a comment against each objective and a suggested mark band.
- Compare (10 minutes). Put the output for your 3 scripts beside your own. If it is more than one band out, tighten the objectives and run it again.
- Read all 30 outputs and set the marks (18 minutes). Edit or delete anything wrong.
Which tool fits which job?
Pick the tool by the job, and check the output the same way whichever you use.
- Planit Teachers marks a class set of pupils’ work against your objectives.
- Brisk gives feedback on pupils’ writing in batches and works inside Google Docs, Slides and PDFs. It fits if your pupils already write in Google Docs.
- Curipod runs live, teacher-led writing lessons. Pupils write, get AI feedback, discuss and revise in the session. Use it during the lesson, not for work you have already collected.
Steps 4 to 6 above suit the first two. With Curipod, read the feedback as pupils receive it and step in when it is off.
Common mistakes to avoid
The most common mistake is trusting a mark you have not checked. These are the others worth watching for.
- Pasting names or personal data into a tool your school has not approved.
- Accepting the suggested mark without reading the pupil’s work.
- Writing vague objectives such as “good writing”. The AI then guesses what you mean.
- Skipping step 3, so you have no benchmark to compare against.
- Sending AI comments to pupils unread. Comments can be generic, wrong or unkind in tone.
Each of these is cheap to avoid if you keep to the order of the steps.
What to do when it goes wrong
If the output is poor, fix the objectives before you change the tool. Most weak results come from loose instructions.
- Comments are generic: add one example of a comment you would write, then run again.
- Marks drift from yours: ask the tool to quote the line of work that supports each judgement, then check those lines.
- You are out of energy: run 10 pieces instead of 30 and mark the rest by hand.
- The tool misreads a piece: mark it yourself and move on. Do not argue with it.
Your three benchmark marks from step 3 are the test. If the tool cannot match them, do not trust it with the other 27.
How to make it easier next time
Save what you built, so the next set takes less than the first. Most of the 60 minutes goes on setting up, and setting up is reusable.
- Keep your objectives and your three benchmark scripts for each task type.
- Save the instructions you gave the tool, with the example comment that worked.
- Keep a short bank of your own edits, such as phrasings you always change.
- Block out the same 60 minutes each time, so it becomes routine.
After two or three class sets, step 3 can shrink, because you will know where the tool tends to be too generous or too harsh. Keep reading every output.
Frequently asked questions
Can I put pupils' names into an AI marking tool?
Only if your school has approved that tool for that use. Otherwise remove names and use pupil numbers. Follow your school's AI and data policy. This is not legal advice.
Should AI decide the final mark?
No. The AI can suggest a mark band and draft a comment, but you set the mark. You know the pupil, the task and the context, and the tool does not.
Which tool can mark a whole class set?
Planit Teachers marks a class set of pupils' work against your objectives. Brisk gives feedback on pupils' writing in batches, inside Google Docs and similar. Curipod is for live writing lessons rather than marking finished work.
How long does marking with AI take?
About 60 minutes for a class set of 30 pieces, if you follow the six steps. That includes writing objectives, marking three scripts yourself and reading every output. Longer pieces will take longer.
When can pupils see the AI's comments?
Only after you have read them and edited anything that is wrong, vague or unkind. Never send AI comments to pupils unread.